Women's Ice Hockey Coaches

Earl Utter, 2023
Earl Utter 
Head Coach 

Phone:  716-926-8870
E-mail:  
 eutter@hilbert.edu

1st season at Hilbert (25 years total)


 

Athletic Director Tim Seil introduced Earl Utter as the new head coach for the Hilbert Women's Hockey program July 20, 2023.  Utter's previous experience starting a pair of first-year Division III hockey programs will guide him as he leads the Hawks into their second season of competition in 2023-24.
 
"I am excited to hire a coach for our Women's Hockey program with Earl's experience," said Seil. "Earl has proven he can have success with young programs at the Division III level. Given his ties to the region, he is a great fit for Hilbert College. We look forward to him leading the Hawks into year two!"
 
The Rochester, N.Y. native recently served as the Wilkes University women's head coach, where he began building his roster in 2017 in anticipation of their first season of NCAA competition in 2018-19.  The Colonels went 5-17-1 in 2019-20, his second season before Covid-19 interrupted his program's progression the following year.  Utter coached four All-MAC (Middle Atlantic Conference) selections and 19 UCHC All-Academic honorees during his four seasons behind the Colonels bench.
 
"I would like to thank Dr. Brophy, Director of Athletics Tim Seil, and God for giving me this opportunity to continue to build the Women's Hockey program at Hilbert College," said Utter.  "I am excited to join the Hilbert community, and I look forward to building the Women's Hockey program into a mountain from a little hill."
 
Utter was the women's head coach at Cortland State for nine seasons prior and guided them to two straight ECAC West playoff appearances in 2014-15 and 2015-16 before he moved to Wilkes.

From 1997-2007, Utter compiled an overall record of 177-60-13 at Morrisville State and led the men's program in its transition from the junior college to NCAA Division III ranks. He guided the Mustangs to four National Junior College Athletic Association (NJCAA) national titles, including three straight from 2004-06 and four in five years.  He was named the NJCAA National Coach of the Year three times.

Utter was also chosen as the Eastern Junior College Hockey League (EJCHL) Coach of the Year on three occasions. His players earned 11 All-America honors along with numerous all-league and all-region awards. Off the ice, his players earned 10 NJCAA Academic All-America and Academic All-Region honors.

Prior to Morrisville, Utter spent two seasons as a volunteer men's and women's assistant coach at Division I Cornell University for two seasons. He has also coached in the North American Hockey League and at the high school and midget levels. In the summer, Utter worked for USA Hockey as an instructor at National Player Development camps and as a lecturer in the USA Hockey Coaching Development programs. He has worked with coaching staffs of two Under-22 national women's teams.

Utter earned a bachelor's degree from SUNY Brockport and a master's degree from Western Michigan University.




 
Payne Shelley Payne 
Volunteer Assistant Coach 

Phone:  716-926-8870
E-mail:  
 spayne@hilbert.edu

2nd season 


 


Shelley Payne served as a volunteer Goalie Coach in 2022.

updated 07/20/2023